A law firm was undermined by a single high-ranking negative blog post appearing prominently in branded searches.
A leading regional law firm known for its aggressive marketing and exceptional service representing accident victims faced an unexpected online reputation threat. Despite significant advertising investment, a single highly-ranked negative blog post was surfacing at the top of brand-related searches — swaying prospective clients before they ever reached the firm's own website.
The damage was measurable: a noticeable decline in new client inquiries was directly attributable to this single piece of content. The firm's marketing spend was being undermined at the last mile — when a prospect was actively considering hiring them.
We pursued a dual-track approach: first attempting to identify and remove the content through digital forensics and outreach, then executing a comprehensive suppression campaign when removal proved impossible. Both tracks ran simultaneously to maximize efficiency.
Deployed innovative tracking techniques, including a pixel embedded in an email, to attempt identification of the blog owner; narrowed down suspects with potential motives; made multiple outreach attempts to request removal — all met with silence.
Developed a comprehensive content strategy highlighting the firm's achievements, client testimonials, awards, and industry recognition to surround and displace the negative result.
Engaged with legal industry influencers and media outlets to amplify the reach of positive content and build the domain authority needed to outrank the negative post.
Implemented targeted search engine marketing to boost the rankings of favorable content on branded search queries, directly competing with the negative post for first-page position.
The negative blog post's prominence in search results began to wane within the first 90 days. Over time, it was demoted to the bottom of the first page, then to the second page — and its influence was effectively neutralized. Visibility was reduced from 90% to under 3%, representing a 97% reduction in exposure to this content.
The firm's advertising investment was restored to full effectiveness, with prospective clients now encountering positive, client-controlled content throughout their research process.
Digital forensics and outreach attempts; suppression strategy developed and content creation underway.
Initial improvement in search rankings observed; positive content appearing above the negative post.
Negative post demoted off the first page; new client inquiries recovering.
Negative post visibility reduced to under 3%; firm's marketing ROI fully restored.
Explore more examples of how we help clients transform their online reputation.
Talk to a strategist today and discover what is possible for your online presence.
Get Your Free Reputation Analysis