An Online Reputation Management Checklist to Solve Minor Issues
Follow this practical checklist to assess, address, and maintain your online reputation before small issues become serious problems.
If you're thinking about improving your online reputation, it helps to have a clear direction before you start. A baseline understanding of your current reputation is necessary before fixing it, and performing a quick Google search on your company or brand name is an easy way to see what's out there.
- Set up TalkWalker or Google Alerts early to catch brand mentions as they happen.
- Read your own reviews on platforms like Google, Facebook, and Angi to spot recurring issues.
- Audit all online profiles for completeness, accuracy, and consistent branding.
- Compare your online presence against at least three competitors to find gaps.
- Identify negative content and determine whether removal, de-indexing, or suppression is appropriate.
This article provides a structured checklist for assessing and improving your online reputation. It covers both the initial audit steps—monitoring mentions, reviewing feedback, checking profile accuracy, and analyzing competitors—and the ongoing maintenance work needed to keep your reputation strong. Following this process helps you identify problem content and take targeted action to address it.
Listen for Mentions — Set Up TalkWalker
TalkWalker Alerts (alerts.talkwalker.com) is a free mention monitoring service worth setting up early. Enter your brand name to start receiving email notifications when it appears online. For more robust tracking, Google Alerts, Brand24, or Semrush's Brand Monitoring are solid alternatives — Google Alerts remains one of the simplest and most reliable free options available.
Examine Your Reviews
Browse social media platforms like Facebook and X (formerly Twitter) to see what people are saying. Check online review sites like Angi as well, and listen to what reviewers say about you. According to BrightLocal's 2024 Local Consumer Review Survey, 98% of consumers read online reviews for local businesses, making this a critical step.
Check Accuracy of Online Profiles
Consider what you look like online to people who don't already know your brand. Your online profiles should have pictures with relevant descriptions, fully completed detail fields, and copy that feels polished and on-brand. This includes your Google Business Profile, which is one of the most visible and impactful profiles for local business reputation.
Level Set Against the Competition
Now that you know how you look online, compare yourself to your top three competitors. Read their articles, read their reviews, and get a clear picture of how they're portrayed online. This competitive analysis helps you understand where you stand relative to others in your space.
Locate Any Problem Online Content
Identify any negative content that may be harming your reputation. Sometimes negative content can be removed, while other times it can be pushed down. Learning the differences between removal, de-indexing, and suppression will help you understand which approach fits your specific situation.
Perform Outreach to a List of Publishers
When you review your competition, note where they have been written about positively. Make a list, then use an outreach program to get mentioned in those same places. Earning positive coverage in reputable publications can significantly strengthen your online reputation.
Get a Free Reputation Assessment
Find out what people see when they search for you online. No obligation — results in 24 hours.
Frequently Asked Questions
Protect Your Online Reputation
Every day you wait, negative content gets stronger. Talk to our experts about a custom strategy for your situation.
Get Your Free Analysis